26 Oct·2 min read

The iPhone Duo's screen is cracking, and iFixit has three suspects

Days after launch, iFixit's teardown points to three likely spots inside Apple's foldable where the screen is failing.

Apple's $2,000 foldable iPhone went on sale on October 23, and within hours owners were posting photos of cracked inner screens. Notebookcheck rounded up the first reports that same day. Apple still hasn't commented.

To see why a folding screen might crack, start with how it's built. Apple calls the inner display a 10-layer stack. There's a nano-textured polymer cover on top, high-strength glass above and below the folding display panel, and a titanium plate at the bottom. The layers are bonded with viscoelastic adhesives, which let them slide past each other as the phone folds. That sliding matters because when you bend a stack of sheets, the layers on the outside of the curve have to travel farther than the ones on the inside. If they couldn't slip, the whole thing would tear itself apart.

Under all of that sits the hinge, and that's where iFixit focused. They rebuilt it in 3D from teardown footage, Apple's patents and CT scans, then compared it against where the reported cracks actually show up. The breaks cluster in one place: where a gap for a flex cable crossing the hinge meets the central hinge support. Several edges come together at that spot, so every fold puts stress on the same small area of the screen above it.

The second suspect is the set of curved rails that follow the hinge's pivot points. iFixit thinks they may lift slightly above the flat hinge plates as the phone closes, and one of those rails lines up with the damage people are seeing. The third is the oldest problem in foldables: a tiny particle gets trapped, and every time you close the phone it gets pressed into the screen. iFixit also lists plain pressure, repeated bending and a manufacturing defect as possible causes.

There's one more wrinkle. iFixit points out that a wiring fault can look exactly like a crack, so some of these displays may not be physically broken at all. That would be better news for owners, though it's still a broken screen on a phone that's been out a few days.

What I find interesting is that the same teardown gave the Duo a provisional repair score of 5 out of 10 and called it the most repairable foldable they've seen so far. So Apple seems to have expected screens to need replacing, and designed for it. Still, I'd want to hear from Apple about which of these it is before buying one. Every company that has shipped a foldable has run into some version of this problem, and Apple waiting this long to try one and still hitting it says a lot about how hard the hinge actually is.